Unveiling the Subtle Line Between Empathy and Sympathy
Imagine it’s the weekend and, after a long day, you have a meet-up with a close friend at a downtown bar. The meeting is a chance to discuss the past week and catch up on recent events. As you chat, you notice that something seems off with your friend—maybe their mind is wandering, and it seems like it’s time to give them the floor because they seem on the verge of breaking down. When it’s their turn to speak, they “dump” on you their recent work experience, describing it as overwhelming and difficult, their mood is sad and desperate, and they even threaten to quit their job.
How would you respond? Since they are your friend and you want to support them, you might say: “I’m sorry you’re going through this, I hope things get better soon.” Do you think this is an empathetic response? I’m sorry to say it’s not; instead, it’s a sympathetic response. But don’t worry, it’s not a big deal, and in the following lines, I’ll explain why.
Empathy Vs Sympathy
Here’s a key point to consider: both empathy and sympathy are valuable qualities. If you’ve been more sympathetic than empathetic in some situations, it doesn’t mean you’ve done anything wrong!
Empathy and sympathy are two terms often mistakenly considered interchangeable when, in fact, they describe different emotional experiences. Let’s start with their etymology. Sympathy comes from the Greek sym-patéo, which means “to feel together” the same emotions, sharing the same emotional reaction to events.
Empathy has a slightly different etymological meaning: from the Greek en-pátheia, it means to be “inside” another person’s feelings, to understand experientially what they are going through, without necessarily agreeing on the interpretation of the triggering events.
Specifically, sympathy involves showing interest, concern, or sorrow for someone, and translates into an urgency to act to make the other person feel better. Sympathy can manifest as attentiveness towards the other person, but unlike empathy, it doesn’t involve a deep identification. On the other hand, empathy fosters a more authentic connection and a deeper emotional bond in relationships.
Returning to the initial example, the response “I’m sorry you’re going through this, I hope things get better soon” is a sympathetic response because you’re showing understanding and concern for your colleague’s situation but without delving into the specifics of their stress or feeling emotionally involved. This demonstrates a form of detached support typical of sympathy.
In contrast, responding empathetically would involve putting yourself in your friend’s shoes, imagining yourself in their situation, and recalling emotions and states of mind you’ve experienced in a similar situation. “Being inside” their emotions would lead you to respond with something like: “I understand how frustrating it can be to struggle with a project; I’ve been through it myself and know it can feel overwhelming. If you want, we can talk about it and see how I can help.” Here, empathy is manifested by acknowledging feelings of frustration and stress, sharing a similar personal experience, and offering concrete support to address the situation.
As Dr. Brené Brown, an American researcher who has spent decades studying various aspects of the human experience, including empathy, puts it: “Empathy is a choice, and it’s a vulnerable one.” To delve deeper into the difference between empathy and sympathy, at the end of this article, you’ll find a link to a clear and thorough video created by Dr. Brown herself.
Which Is Better—Empathy or Sympathy?
The answer isn’t so clear-cut: neither one is better! Both empathy and sympathy are necessary for emotional and mental well-being, but the context is what really matters.
Empathy is crucial for building and maintaining personal relationships (with friends, family, and romantic partners). Without understanding the other person’s perspective and what moves them emotionally, it’s hard to communicate effectively and resolve conflicts. For example, if you can’t empathize, instead of finding common ground, you might end up focusing solely on convincing the other person of your own viewpoint.
While it may seem negative, the inherent detachment of sympathy is actually its strength. Sympathy is useful in social contexts where full empathy might not be appropriate or possible. In more formal situations or when you don’t have a close relationship with someone, sympathy still allows you to show respect and understanding. Sympathy acts as an emotional bridge that maintains a healthy distance between people, enabling them to offer support without becoming overwhelmed by others’ emotions. Think about the struggling news we receive daily from around the world—sympathizing with these events helps protect us from becoming too involved. One of the major risks of excessive empathy is empathy fatigue (or compassion fatigue), a state of emotional and mental exhaustion that occurs when someone is exposed to the pain and suffering of others over long periods, as often happens in helping professions like medicine, nursing, psychology, and social work, but it can affect anyone constantly involved in supporting people in distress.
So, what’s the solution? Finding the right balance between sympathy and empathy, sometimes using both to support each other. Sympathy can serve as a starting point for recognizing and validating someone else’s suffering, showing that you care about their situation as an initial expression of emotional closeness. Empathy can then come into play to connect on a deeper level, seeking to understand how the other truly feels and aligning with their emotions.
Test Your Knowledge
Try to solve the exercises provided below. Your task is to read each scenario and determine whether the response is empathetic, sympathetic, or both.
Exercise 1: Watching Sad News
You are watching the news on TV and see that a natural disaster has just struck a population on the Pacific coast. Your reaction might be: “It’s really sad what has happened to those people.”
Answers:
A) Empathetic response
B) Sympathetic response
C) Both
Exercise 2: Anxiety About an Exam
A friend tells you that they are very anxious about an upcoming exam. Your response is: “It seems like you’re really under pressure. What is the thing that worries you most about this exam?”
Answers:
A) Empathetic response
B) Sympathetic response
C) Both
Exercise 3: A Friend Has Lost a Loved One
A friend tells you they have lost a loved one. Your response is: “I’m so sorry for your loss; it’s truly sad. I can’t imagine how much pain you’re going through, but if you want to talk or need anything, I’m here for you.”
Answers:
A) Empathetic response
B) Sympathetic response
C) Both
Solutions:
1) B
2) A
3) C